PDA

View Full Version : Whale Wars brings this into focus for me


JeepMike
11-17-2008, 11:19 PM
Hey guys,

Just wondering what your thoughts were on the assembly of people that show up and attempt to "save" beached whales? Have you ever thought about this; waded through the romantic, fluffy bunny side of it and thought about just what the hell it is these people are doing? It's a noggin scratcher for me.
I understand why scientist rush down to a beached whale as this presents a wonderful opportunity for research. But for the "whale teams" of people that drop every thing they are doing in their hometowns 500 miles away, haul ass to splash buckets of water on a beached whale, try to push it back in the water, and then stare condescendingly to anyone who dares just walk/drive by; what the hell are they doing? It's like they think they are the freakin "A Team" or something. Just this summer a baby sperm whale beached himself in Avon, and I went to check things out.

Well the "whale team" had assembled and had "taken over" the area. There was some guy that seemed to be in charge of this whole ordeal barking orders like they were about to launch a rocket into space. I began asking questions and a few of them had comments such as "Well are you going to just talk, or help", and "sorry, (panting for breath), can't talk now", or a "if your not helping go away".

Last time I checked it wasn't my responsibility to keep a whale from swimming his a$$ on the beach, it was HIS!! When someone with credentials from ECU finally showed up he told me that the overwhelming majority of these are whales that beach themselves are dying or very sick and will die soon.

Well the "A Team" did get him back in the water and cheered with delight but then freaked out again when the whale made an abrupt U turn before the 2nd bar and beach himself again!!! Then it was panic, and some of them even cried when it died and someone showed up to cut the body up and bury it.

I would certainly help any critter I could if it was in apparent unnatural distress, so I don't want to come across as a heartless fella.

What the hell is going on here? Yes, if 1,000 whales showed up on a beach one day in distress that would be sad, but I can't see why people would be so bent out of shape over one whale doing something perfectly natural.

These people remind me alot of the storm chasers out west, most of them are morons that just want a glimpse of the wild side and do so in the name of weather spotting, making the pros look bad.

Sorry for the rant, but thats what the lounge is for right?

wolfva
11-18-2008, 02:29 AM
I think that by 'helping' they boost their own ego. It's not about the whale, it's about them doing something that makes them feel good. Of course, some whales that are rescued actually do go on living; sometimes man made noises and such confuses them and they wind up on a beach where they don't want to be. But an immanciated or obviousely sick cetacean? Odds are real good it's trying to die so, if anything, help it along.

Lipyourown
11-18-2008, 11:05 AM
Do you ever try to help a lame or stuck horse or do you just let nature take it's course? I suspect most people who help stranded whales do it for similar reasons that you helped those dogfish on the pier.

SkunkApe
11-18-2008, 11:39 AM
Way back when...the Indians used to have a field day when whales beached themselves on the sands up here in the coastal areas. Free grub with minimal effort to obtain it. Just nature taking it's course, to the advantage of the bipeds over the seagoing mammalians.

I don't think anyone will ever understand why the whales/dolphins commit suicide and the other "Koolaid drinkin" finned ones follow suit. The pointy heads have been trying to figure that one out for years.

One of my liberal friends swears up and down it's the Navy's fault for blasting high powered sonar signals, but I tell her that the whales/dolphins have been killing themselves since Torak the caveman was hauling his woman around by the hair....:D

http://i233.photobucket.com/albums/ee209/riverrat3571/cave-MAN.jpg

Skunk

jhmorgan
11-18-2008, 12:37 PM
Im sure its the same reason that people stop and help a baby bird that dropped out of its nest, or the same reason people help a baby squirrel/raccoon/grizzly bear/bobcat that has been abandoned by momma, or the same reason a hunter lowers his gun after seeing his game limping around. Humans like to save things, its the reason tht we do not throw premature babies into the gutter, the same reason that we have life support ,the same reason for many things. We have a sense of caring, and a sense of guilt and remorse if we do not attempt to help.

Irony is, of course, that we do far more harm to the natural world than we could ever hope to ammend for. Of course this is not a new age idea. The Native Americans used to run entire herds of buffalos off of cliffs in the pre-European days. 1000's of buffalos would follow their Alpha leader to a bloody death so that a couple of hundred Indians could eat. Imagine how many carcasses were left behind by even the most resourceful Indian?

Off topic, a tad bit, but I tried to come full circle.